Prayer of the Faithful
November 21, 2026
Question: How many Prayers of the Faithful should be offered during the Eucharistic celebration? What is the proper format, and what kinds of intentions should be included? — S.T., Mumbai, India
Hands at the Our Father
November 15, 2026
Question: In India, it is common to observe many of the faithful, and even concelebrating priests, extending their hands during the Our Father at Mass. However, it is my understanding that the gesture of extending hands (orans posture) is prescribed only for the principal celebrant, as indicated in the Missal: “He extends his hands and, together with the people, continues.” In this context, what is the appropriate posture or gesture for concelebrants and for the faithful during the Our Father? Furthermore, do bishops’ conferences or the local ordinary have the authority to determine or regulate such gestures? In the absence of explicit directives, is it permissible for the faithful to adopt gestures of their own choosing during this prayer? — G.C., Bengaluru, India
Protestant Songs Within Mass
November 8, 2026
Question: What need do we have and what benefits does it bring to the Catholic Church, to sing Protestant songs within Mass? We are not Protestants! Some mention ecumenism, but I have not seen many Protestants attend Mass even if this were a good reason to sing such hymns. If we think about what the vast majority of Protestant composers think of our holy Church and of the Supreme Pontiff, we would not open our doors to say, as some people do, that if the text does not go against what the Catholic Church teaches, then there would be no problem in singing it at Mass. There are many singers in local churches who have very little or no formation in this field, and it is dangerous to open our doors to Protestant songs on the grounds that there are no documents explicitly banning them. There are many very vulnerable people who, when they hear a Protestant song, because there is no doubt that many of the songs are very beautiful, eventually might arrive at the point of joining the Protestants. I hope that the Holy Spirit will guide those who are in charge of this to make good decisions so that souls are not lost! — N.P., Nashville, Tennessee
Proclaiming the Gospel Outside of Mass
November 1, 2026
Question: Could you please clarify if the presider should follow the same protocol used during Mass when proclaiming the Gospel in other services, such as group prayers, child baptisms, or funeral home vigils? I do not see a clear instruction as in the Order of the Mass. — N.T., Houston, Texas
Which Way the Celebrant Should Face
October 25, 2026
Question: I know that with the references to the General Instruction of the Roman Missal [GIRM] and Order of Mass, it is a little longer than normal, but this is how far I got in my own research before I could not find any more answers.
Orans Gesture at Funerals
October 18, 2026
Question: My question is related to the position of a priest’s hands in some of the prayers at funerals. For the prayer of commendation and committal, what is the proper gesture for the priest? The rite doesn't seem to specify. There are other prayers that don't seem to specify the gestures; I have seen different ways (for example, the concluding prayer of vespers—orans?). What are some principles to help guide the use of gestures in prayer if the liturgical books do not specify? — P.T., Baltimore, Maryland
Candles for Communion to the Sick
October 11, 2026
Question: Many older artistic representations which show Communion being taken to the sick strongly feature the presence of a candle, sometimes borne by a server or servers, but it seems very uncommon for this to happen today. When a cleric or an extraordinary minister of Holy Communion removes hosts from the tabernacle to distribute them to the homebound and the sick, should candles be lit either side of the tabernacle? Should this also occur when Hosts are replaced back in the tabernacle? Should a candle or candles be lit in the homes or hospital rooms where one gives the homebound and sick Communion? Could or should one or more available altar servers carry a candle on the way to each home if this were practically possible? Finally, are there any universal norms about the required liturgical vestments for this rite? — J.D., Wagga Wagga, Australia
Omission of the Consecration at Mass
October 4, 2026
Question: During a Sunday Mass at church the priest forgot to do the consecration of the bread and wine. He was in his 50s and looked healthy. A priest assistant tried to tell the priest, but he was not aware. So, the communion was distributed without the consecration having been done. This case has been reported to the archbishop. If this happens at a Mass I attend, what should I do? Should I attend another Mass? What if I cannot attend the next Mass? — M.Y., Jakarta, Indonesia
When Words of Absolution Are Changed
September 26, 2026
Question: At confession, if a confessor says, “I forgive you all your sins” instead “I absolve you of your sins,” is that confession valid? — B.B., Calgary, Alberta
Deacons, Communion and Benediction
September 13, 2026
Question 1: I've been attending a local daily Mass where there are a priest and a deacon. For distribution of Communion, the priest has been cleaning the vessels while the deacon distributes the hosts. Should it be the other way around? — T.F., Cortland, New York
Question 2: May a permanent deacon, in the absence of a priest, preside the Benediction with the Blessed Sacrament at the conclusion of the time of exposition? — N.F., Nouméa, New Caledonia